Penny is a young girl down in luck and looking for that perfect guy. When she wishes for an intellectual guy and throws her penny in the water. With a shock her wish comes true, and this starts a series of wishes that just don’t quite go right. She wishes for a romantic guy, what she gets is the same guy but acting all romantic. Her third wish brings the same guy back but with a more Australian persona. When she goes to make her next wish she finally acknowledges the beggar who had been there all along and decides to stop throwing away her money and lend a hand. She turns to walk away when all of a sudden she steps on a penny, looking up to find her perfect guy.