Andy Cutler is waiting impatiently for his girlfriend, Danielle Newcombe, who is running very late. He’s called her multiple times with no answer. Andy finally sees the headlights pull into their driveway, but when he goes to the door, it’s not Danielle who greets him. Andy and Danielle are the perfect couple, but when tragedy strikes Danielle, the police force led by Detective Steve Monroe have no leads. Dissatisfied with the police’s efforts, Andy is forced to choose between following his heart and his mind when he thinks he discovers evidence of his own. When a shadowy figure is seen following someone around town, it becomes unclear who is the real criminal.