In one of biggest surprises in "Bachelor" or "Bachelorette" history, Andrew Firestone, the man who first proposed to Jen in April 2003 during the third installment of "The Bachelor," confronts the 23 rejected men who have left the show - including Stu, who was dubbed a "stalker" by the other guys, and Fabrice, who walked out on Jen before the rose ceremony. Andrew offers his opinion of the men, their unkind comments about him and their behavior towards his former sweetheart, as well as sets the record straight on the real story of his break-up with Jen. What does Andrew really think about Jen's second attempt to find love? In addition, the men who did not receive roses from Jen reunite to give the behind-the-scenes lowdown, attempting to resolve lingering conflicts among themselves and offering their predictions on which of the two remaining men she's likely to choose.