One of TJ’s (Marley Ficalora, Law and Order: SVU) fondest childhood memories is fishing with his Uncle Mack (Robert John Burke, RoboCop) out in Montauk. Uncle Mack used fishing as a way to teach young TJ lessons about life. These fishing memories/lessons come back to haunt TJ in present day. TJ arrives in Montauk during the off-season expecting his Uncle Mack to be there but he is instead nowhere to be found. After coming to terms with his Uncle Mack’s absence TJ returns to his childhood room where he meets a stranger (James McCaffrey, Rescue Me) who is looking for a room. After dismissing the stranger an unsuspecting TJ finds out that things aren’t always the way they seem.