Newlyweds Peter and Holly moved into a fixer-upper with big designer dreams. Holly thought she knew exactly what she wanted from all the design programs she watched on tv. Less than a year after moving in, they realized what a challenge it is to renovate a home. Designer Hilary and realtor David step in to help. Hilary and her team work to transform the home into what Peter and Holly always wanted. Meanwhile, David will show them houses that could fit them perfectly without renovations. After everything has been done, the couple must choose what's best for their home. Should they Love It? Or List It?